--- title: Partial Transactions Testing Back-Fill — 2026-10-23 examined_at: '2026-10-23' examiner: codex source_sha: services-accounting: f47cb263875bbc0c5640fba7dae6785ec32695f8 react-console: baf6dae382d6f41dce976c7f848667ccc37e076f rhythm-v2-docs: 43a78e3d30f068c179036184c87e11b2214e227c branch: agent/accounting-transactions-testing-1 completion: 'partial: required report-name compatibility awaits a scope exception' product_intent: proposed counts: specifications_extended: 20 existing_scenarios_retained: 175 scenarios_added: 25 scenarios_added_by_category: rule: 0 transition: 0 validation: 0 permission: 0 edge: 0 failure: 0 boundary: 3 concurrency: 1 invariant: 1 interaction: 20 feature_suites_written: 6 feature_scenarios_written: 30 executable_suites_registered: 358 executable_suites_by_repository: services-accounting: 153 react-console: 205 executable_suites_by_kind: api-lifecycle: 57 browser-lifecycle: 168 unit: 22 integration: 111 original_file_bindings_retained: 508 new_file_assertion_bindings: 3 suite_scenario_bindings: 261 assertion_bindings: 511 feature_suite_bindings: 0 new_findings: 25 new_coverage_gap_findings: 23 new_inconsistency_findings: 1 category_gaps: 65 transition_mapping_gap_occurrences: 179 permission_mapping_gap_occurrences: 90 invariant_mapping_gaps: 15 unbound_capability_scenarios: 30 unbound_feature_scenarios: 30 unmapped_executable_suites: 229 new_tooling_debt_findings: 1 inventory_scope: services-accounting: - modules/transactions/tests/e2e/*.spec.js - modules/transactions/tests/integration/**/*.spec.js - modules/transactions/tests/unit/**/*.spec.js react-console: - acceptance/accounting/playwright/journeys/invoices/*.spec.ts - acceptance/accounting/playwright/journeys/payments/*.spec.ts - acceptance/accounting/playwright/journeys/cross-application/*.spec.ts - >- acceptance/accounting/playwright/journeys/{adversarial,batches-posting,billing,configuration,products,reconciliation-close,reporting,security-integrations}/**: files with Transactions calls or financial assertions - >- e2e/**: invoice, collection, credit, return, account and financial-record screen suites in scope counting_notes: - >- Original file citations remain intact; the three new file assertion citations support two new capability scenarios. - >- A suite-scenario link is counted once for a pair even if several assertions contribute; assertion citations are counted separately. - >- Transition and permission counts are mapping-gap occurrences across specifications, not counts of distinct state paths or grants. - >- Covered categories contain specified examples; complete guard, actor, side-effect and grant combinations remain explicitly flagged where not mapped. - >- All thirty feature scenarios remain proposed and unbound; a component test is not promoted into proof of a complete feature chain. - >- API-only Playwright files are registered as API lifecycle suites rather than claiming staff browser coverage. validation: - command: npm ci && npm run check result: passed errors: 0 warnings: 6901 provenance: observed source: 'rhythm-v2-docs:package.json#scripts.check' note: >- This passing checkpoint uses the currently recognized examination-report filename; the requested report filename is separately blocked. - command: npm test result: passed tests: 4 failed: 0 provenance: observed source: 'rhythm-v2-docs:package.json#scripts.test' - command: Authoring audit result: passed checks: - permanent allocations - original scenario and binding retention - ten category maps - related capability and workflow companion coverage - must-prove rule references - feature membership and all five scenario kinds - existing executable files - reciprocal suite bindings - suite body sections - no execution or approval promotion provenance: observed source: 'rhythm-v2-docs:specs/accounting/transactions/**' evidence: - 'rhythm-v2-docs:specs/CONVENTIONS.md#5.3, #9.10, #10, #6' - >- rhythm-v2-docs:specs/templates/CAPABILITY-TEST-SPECIFICATION.md; FEATURE-ACCEPTANCE-SUITE.md; EXECUTABLE-TEST-SUITE.md - 'rhythm-v2-docs:specs/accounting/transactions/MODULE.md#artifact_tree' - 'rhythm-v2-docs:specs/accounting/transactions/FINDINGS.md#finding_evidence' - >- services-accounting:modules/transactions/tests: existing assertions, fixtures and test-double declarations - >- react-console:acceptance/accounting/playwright; e2e: scoped executable files and their financial calls and assertions remaining: - work: >- Admit the requested dated testing back-fill report name in the existing report validator. file: tools/check-corpus.mjs scope_exception: pending user approval finding: FND-ACC-TRX-090 - work: >- Move this examination report to the required filename, remove the Partial qualifier and rerun both acceptance commands. file: specs/accounting/transactions/reports/TESTING-BACKFILL-2026-10-23.md depends_on: report-name compatibility --- # Partial Transactions Testing Back-Fill ## Counts | Measure | Count | |---|---:| | Capability specifications moved and extended | 20 | | Existing capability scenarios retained | 175 | | Capability scenarios added | 25 | | New boundary scenarios | 3 | | New concurrency scenarios | 1 | | New invariant scenarios | 1 | | New interaction scenarios | 20 | | Feature acceptance suites written | 6 | | Feature scenarios written | 30 | | Executable suites registered | 358 | | Suite-to-scenario bindings made | 261 | | Assertion bindings recorded | 511 | | Original file citations retained | 508 | | Coverage-gap findings recorded | 23 | | Implementation-inconsistency findings recorded | 1 | | Report-name tooling debt recorded | 1 | | Category gaps retained | 65 | | Unbound capability scenarios | 30 | | Unbound feature scenarios | 30 | | Registered suites awaiting scenario mapping | 229 | The structured counts include all ten categories, including those with no added scenarios. State-path and permission mapping gaps remain separate from category examples so their exact combinations are still visible. ## Validation Dependency installation and corpus conformance pass with zero errors for the checked examination-report checkpoint; the shared corpus still reports warnings. The repository test runner passes all four tests, and the authoring audit checks allocations, retained citations, capability relationships, feature membership, executable files and reciprocal bindings. No registered Accounting or console executable suite is run during this documentation job. ## Verdict The Transactions testing hierarchy is back-filled with capability specifications, cumulative feature suites and a register of existing executable suites. Coverage remains incomplete, with explicit findings for missing categories, exact state and permission combinations, unbound feature chains and assertions awaiting a capability home. The required report name still awaits a permitted compatibility change, while executable suites remain unrun and the back-fill establishes no product approval. ## Remaining Work The remaining work is limited to admitting the requested testing report name, moving this report to that name and repeating the acceptance checks. The compatibility edit falls outside the job’s permitted corpus paths, so the scope exception remains pending.