Metadata Planning Examination
Examination method
Codex examined the planning layer against the two pinned source trees, including route contracts, persistence services, table definitions, console configuration and record components, test assertions and the product records cited by the artifacts. Reference checks opened pinned files and checked test titles and source symbols; product decisions were considered separately from implementation evidence. Annotation text following documentary headings is descriptive citation context rather than an exact heading.
The requested planning brief is absent from the starting checkout and fetched default branch. The supplied job instructions and available product records govern this examination, while compliance with the unavailable brief remains unresolved. No service or browser acceptance suite was executed in this job, and an existing test binding does not claim a passing execution at these commits.
Counts and grain
The examination covers fifty-nine module artifacts and six Platform actor rows: one charter, one registry, one findings register, six features, six concepts, nineteen capabilities, six journeys and nineteen acceptance sets. The concepts contain between five hundred and six hundred words each and retain six explanatory sections. The capability boundaries group coherent outcomes; no existing capability or concept identifier was merged, split or renumbered.
| Measure | Starting layer | Examined layer |
|---|---|---|
| Rule rows | 183 | 188 |
| Must-prove rules | 154 | 171 |
| Acceptance scenarios | 151 | 164 |
| Findings | 30 | 41 |
| Product questions | 3 | 3 |
All must-prove rules have an acceptance scenario or an explicitly linked finding. This is obligation coverage rather than complete bound proof. Product approval remains Andrew’s decision, and the loads and announcements capabilities retain proposed intent.
Coverage against pinned code
| Inventory | Covered / total | Home | Uncovered by name |
|---|---|---|---|
| Literal route operations | 86 / 86 | Operation map below | None |
| Generated health operations | 3 / 3 | Operational metadata | None |
| Tables and views | 26 / 26 | Storage map below | None |
| Published permission keys | 41 / 41 | Permission map below, including dependency and finding homes | None |
| Scoped service end-to-end files | 16 / 16 | Test-file map below | None |
| Custom-object browser specifications | 26 / 26 | Acceptance bindings and journeys | None |
| Legacy custom-object capability identities | 112 / 112 | Supersession references | None |
| State machines | 0 / 0 | None declared in scope | None |
| Work queues | 1 / 1 | Event delivery capability | None |
| Schedules | 2 / 2 | Event dispatch and retention capability | None |
| Registration functions | 1 / 1 | Registration capability | None |
| Scoped console page files | 21 / 21 | Charter hosted surfaces | None |
Inventory coverage does not establish all product promises. The remaining named proof gaps include collection retirement, native-category presentation support, attachment save ownership, contact-form rendering, recipe archival, untouched hidden values, archived-record deletion, historical property presentation, queued-event retention and cross-service lifecycle cleanup. Their finding homes appear below.
Operation map
| Operation | Capability |
|---|---|
listFieldTypes | CAP-PFM-MTD-002 |
listObjects | CAP-PFM-MTD-002 |
describeObject | CAP-PFM-MTD-002 |
setFieldLabel | CAP-PFM-MTD-004 |
removeFieldLabel | CAP-PFM-MTD-004 |
listCustomFields | CAP-PFM-MTD-005 |
createCustomField | CAP-PFM-MTD-005 |
getCustomField | CAP-PFM-MTD-005 |
updateCustomField | CAP-PFM-MTD-005 |
archiveCustomField | CAP-PFM-MTD-005 |
restoreCustomField | CAP-PFM-MTD-005 |
getCustomFieldRules | CAP-PFM-MTD-006 |
setCustomFieldRules | CAP-PFM-MTD-006 |
issueFileUpload | CAP-PFM-MTD-007 |
getFilesHealth | CAP-PFM-MTD-007 |
createConsolePageLayout | CAP-PFM-MTD-008 |
getConsolePageLayout | CAP-PFM-MTD-008 |
updateConsolePageLayout | CAP-PFM-MTD-008 |
patchConsolePageLayout | CAP-PFM-MTD-008 |
deleteConsolePageLayout | CAP-PFM-MTD-008 |
createPortalPageLayout | CAP-PFM-MTD-008 |
getPortalPageLayout | CAP-PFM-MTD-008 |
updatePortalPageLayout | CAP-PFM-MTD-008 |
patchPortalPageLayout | CAP-PFM-MTD-008 |
deletePortalPageLayout | CAP-PFM-MTD-008 |
createConsoleForm | CAP-PFM-MTD-008 |
getConsoleForm | CAP-PFM-MTD-008 |
updateConsoleForm | CAP-PFM-MTD-008 |
patchConsoleForm | CAP-PFM-MTD-008 |
deleteConsoleForm | CAP-PFM-MTD-008 |
createPortalForm | CAP-PFM-MTD-008 |
getPortalForm | CAP-PFM-MTD-008 |
updatePortalForm | CAP-PFM-MTD-008 |
patchPortalForm | CAP-PFM-MTD-008 |
deletePortalForm | CAP-PFM-MTD-008 |
listConsolePageLayouts | CAP-PFM-MTD-008 |
listPortalPageLayouts | CAP-PFM-MTD-008 |
listConsoleForms | CAP-PFM-MTD-008 |
listPortalForms | CAP-PFM-MTD-008 |
listCustomObjects | CAP-PFM-MTD-009 |
createCustomObject | CAP-PFM-MTD-009 |
getCustomObject | CAP-PFM-MTD-009 |
updateCustomObject | CAP-PFM-MTD-009 |
activateCustomObject | CAP-PFM-MTD-009 |
archiveCustomObject | CAP-PFM-MTD-009 |
restoreCustomObject | CAP-PFM-MTD-009 |
getCustomObjectsHealth | CAP-PFM-MTD-009 |
listCustomApps | CAP-PFM-MTD-010 |
createCustomApp | CAP-PFM-MTD-010 |
getCustomApp | CAP-PFM-MTD-010 |
updateCustomApp | CAP-PFM-MTD-010 |
archiveCustomApp | CAP-PFM-MTD-010 |
restoreCustomApp | CAP-PFM-MTD-010 |
getCustomObjectsNavigation | CAP-PFM-MTD-010 |
listCustomObjectRecords | CAP-PFM-MTD-012 |
createCustomObjectRecord | CAP-PFM-MTD-012 |
getCustomObjectRecord | CAP-PFM-MTD-012 |
updateCustomObjectRecord | CAP-PFM-MTD-012 |
replaceCustomObjectRecord | CAP-PFM-MTD-012 |
publishCustomObjectRecord | CAP-PFM-MTD-013 |
archiveCustomObjectRecord | CAP-PFM-MTD-013 |
restoreCustomObjectRecord | CAP-PFM-MTD-013 |
deleteCustomObjectRecord | CAP-PFM-MTD-013 |
listCustomObjectRecordHistory | CAP-PFM-MTD-014 |
getCustomObjectRecordRevision | CAP-PFM-MTD-014 |
listCustomObjectRecordHistoryActors | CAP-PFM-MTD-014 |
submitAssociationDataJob | CAP-PFM-MTD-016 |
listAssociationDataJobs | CAP-PFM-MTD-016 |
getAssociationDataJob | CAP-PFM-MTD-016 |
listAssociationDataJobResults | CAP-PFM-MTD-016 |
listAssociationDataJobRejections | CAP-PFM-MTD-016 |
applyAssociationDataJob | CAP-PFM-MTD-016 |
pauseAssociationDataJob | CAP-PFM-MTD-016 |
resumeAssociationDataJob | CAP-PFM-MTD-016 |
cancelAssociationDataJob | CAP-PFM-MTD-016 |
retryAssociationDataJob | CAP-PFM-MTD-016 |
listAssociationTypes | CAP-PFM-MTD-017 |
createAssociationType | CAP-PFM-MTD-017 |
getAssociationType | CAP-PFM-MTD-017 |
updateAssociationType | CAP-PFM-MTD-017 |
deleteAssociationType | CAP-PFM-MTD-017 |
listRecordAssociations | CAP-PFM-MTD-018 |
createAssociation | CAP-PFM-MTD-018 |
updateAssociation | CAP-PFM-MTD-018 |
endAssociation | CAP-PFM-MTD-018 |
deleteAssociation | CAP-PFM-MTD-018 |
Tables by capability
| Table file | Capabilities |
|---|---|
registered-objects.table.ts | CAP-PFM-MTD-001, CAP-PFM-MTD-002, CAP-PFM-MTD-003 |
registered-fields.table.ts | CAP-PFM-MTD-001, CAP-PFM-MTD-002 |
registered-collections.table.ts | CAP-PFM-MTD-001, CAP-PFM-MTD-002 |
custom-fields.table.ts | CAP-PFM-MTD-005 |
custom-field-rules.table.ts | CAP-PFM-MTD-006 |
standard-field-label-overrides.table.ts | CAP-PFM-MTD-004 |
current-and-former-users.view.ts (view) | CAP-PFM-MTD-002 |
console-page-layouts.table.ts | CAP-PFM-MTD-008 |
portal-page-layouts.table.ts | CAP-PFM-MTD-008 |
console-forms.table.ts | CAP-PFM-MTD-008 |
portal-forms.table.ts | CAP-PFM-MTD-008 |
layout-assignments.table.ts | CAP-PFM-MTD-008 |
custom-objects.table.ts | CAP-PFM-MTD-009, CAP-PFM-MTD-010, CAP-PFM-MTD-011 |
custom-apps.table.ts | CAP-PFM-MTD-010 |
custom-object-records.table.ts | CAP-PFM-MTD-012, CAP-PFM-MTD-013 |
custom-object-record-values.table.ts | CAP-PFM-MTD-012 |
custom-object-unique-values.table.ts | CAP-PFM-MTD-006, CAP-PFM-MTD-012 |
managed-assets.table.ts | CAP-PFM-MTD-012, CAP-PFM-MTD-013 |
record-revisions.table.ts | CAP-PFM-MTD-014 |
custom-object-record-change-events.table.ts | CAP-PFM-MTD-014 |
business-events.table.ts | CAP-PFM-MTD-015 |
business-event-queue.table.ts | CAP-PFM-MTD-015 |
association-types.table.ts | CAP-PFM-MTD-017 |
associations.table.ts | CAP-PFM-MTD-018, CAP-PFM-MTD-019 |
association-change-events.table.ts | CAP-PFM-MTD-014, CAP-PFM-MTD-018 |
file-uploads.table.ts | CAP-PFM-MTD-007 |
Permission map
| Permission key | Capability or evidence home |
|---|---|
platform.metadata.read | CAP-PFM-MTD-002, CAP-PFM-MTD-003 |
platform.metadata.create, .update, .delete, .bulk | Catalogue-only keys; no requiring route (FND-PFM-MTD-007) |
platform.custom-fields.read | CAP-PFM-MTD-005, CAP-PFM-MTD-006 |
platform.custom-fields.create | CAP-PFM-MTD-005 |
platform.custom-fields.update | CAP-PFM-MTD-005, CAP-PFM-MTD-006 |
platform.custom-fields.delete | CAP-PFM-MTD-005 |
platform.custom-fields.bulk | MOD-PFM-OPS dependency (custom field data jobs); CAP-PFM-MTD-016 evidence |
platform.field-labels.update | CAP-PFM-MTD-004 |
platform.field-labels.read, .create, .delete, .bulk | Catalogue-only keys; no requiring route (FND-PFM-MTD-007) |
platform.layouts.read | CAP-PFM-MTD-008 |
platform.layouts.create | CAP-PFM-MTD-008 |
platform.layouts.update | CAP-PFM-MTD-008 |
platform.layouts.delete | CAP-PFM-MTD-008 |
platform.layouts.bulk | Catalogue-only keys; no requiring route (FND-PFM-MTD-007) |
platform.custom-objects.read | CAP-PFM-MTD-009, CAP-PFM-MTD-010, CAP-PFM-MTD-008 |
platform.custom-objects.create | CAP-PFM-MTD-009, CAP-PFM-MTD-010 |
platform.custom-objects.update | CAP-PFM-MTD-009, CAP-PFM-MTD-010, CAP-PFM-MTD-008 |
platform.custom-objects.delete | CAP-PFM-MTD-009, CAP-PFM-MTD-010, CAP-PFM-MTD-008 |
platform.custom-records.read | CAP-PFM-MTD-011, CAP-PFM-MTD-012, CAP-PFM-MTD-010, CAP-PFM-MTD-008 |
platform.custom-records.query | CAP-PFM-MTD-011; MOD-PFM-QRY dependency |
platform.custom-records.create | CAP-PFM-MTD-011, CAP-PFM-MTD-012, CAP-PFM-MTD-016 |
platform.custom-records.update | CAP-PFM-MTD-011, CAP-PFM-MTD-012, CAP-PFM-MTD-016 |
platform.custom-records.delete | CAP-PFM-MTD-011, CAP-PFM-MTD-013 |
platform.custom-records.publish | CAP-PFM-MTD-011, CAP-PFM-MTD-013 |
platform.custom-records.export | CAP-PFM-MTD-011 (no route; FND-PFM-MTD-030) |
platform.custom-records.history | CAP-PFM-MTD-011, CAP-PFM-MTD-014 |
platform.association-types.read | CAP-PFM-MTD-017 |
platform.association-types.create | CAP-PFM-MTD-017 |
platform.association-types.update | CAP-PFM-MTD-017 |
platform.association-types.delete | CAP-PFM-MTD-017 |
platform.associations.read | CAP-PFM-MTD-018 |
platform.associations.create | CAP-PFM-MTD-018, CAP-PFM-MTD-016 |
platform.associations.update | CAP-PFM-MTD-018, CAP-PFM-MTD-016 |
platform.associations.delete | CAP-PFM-MTD-018 |
platform.files.upload | CAP-PFM-MTD-007 |
Test-file map
| Spec file | Capabilities |
|---|---|
metadata/tests/e2e/custom-fields.e2e.spec.js | CAP-PFM-MTD-005 |
metadata/tests/e2e/metadata-api-observability.e2e.spec.js | CAP-PFM-MTD-005 (operational request instrumentation) |
metadata/tests/e2e/registered-objects.e2e.spec.js | CAP-PFM-MTD-001, CAP-PFM-MTD-002, CAP-PFM-MTD-003 |
metadata/tests/e2e/standard-field-label-overrides.e2e.spec.js | CAP-PFM-MTD-004 |
layouts/tests/e2e/console-forms-api.e2e.spec.js | CAP-PFM-MTD-008 |
layouts/tests/e2e/console-page-layouts-api.e2e.spec.js | CAP-PFM-MTD-008 |
layouts/tests/e2e/custom-object-forms.e2e.spec.js | CAP-PFM-MTD-008 |
layouts/tests/e2e/portal-forms-api.e2e.spec.js | CAP-PFM-MTD-008 |
layouts/tests/e2e/portal-page-layouts-api.e2e.spec.js | CAP-PFM-MTD-008 |
custom-objects/tests/e2e/business-events.e2e.spec.js | CAP-PFM-MTD-015 |
custom-objects/tests/e2e/custom-apps.e2e.spec.js | CAP-PFM-MTD-010 |
custom-objects/tests/e2e/custom-object-record-history.e2e.spec.js | CAP-PFM-MTD-014 |
custom-objects/tests/e2e/custom-object-records.e2e.spec.js | CAP-PFM-MTD-010, CAP-PFM-MTD-011, CAP-PFM-MTD-012 |
custom-objects/tests/e2e/custom-objects.e2e.spec.js | CAP-PFM-MTD-005, CAP-PFM-MTD-006, CAP-PFM-MTD-009 |
associations/tests/e2e/associations.e2e.spec.js | CAP-PFM-MTD-017, CAP-PFM-MTD-018 |
files/tests/e2e/files.e2e.spec.js | CAP-PFM-MTD-007 |
Verification changes by artifact
| Artifact | Verified correction or addition |
|---|---|
BR-CAP-PFM-MTD-001-07 | Added proof obligation. |
BR-CAP-PFM-MTD-002-08 | Added proof obligation. |
BR-CAP-PFM-MTD-004-05 | Added proof obligation. |
BR-CAP-PFM-MTD-004-06 | Added proof obligation. |
BR-CAP-PFM-MTD-005-08 | Corrected behavior statement; Corrected evidence classification; Replaced evidence reference. |
BR-CAP-PFM-MTD-005-09 | Corrected behavior statement. |
BR-CAP-PFM-MTD-005-11 | Corrected behavior statement. |
BR-CAP-PFM-MTD-006-09 | Added proof obligation. |
BR-CAP-PFM-MTD-008-08 | Added proof obligation. |
BR-CAP-PFM-MTD-008-03 | Corrected enforcement boundary. |
BR-CAP-PFM-MTD-008-04 | Corrected enforcement boundary. |
BR-CAP-PFM-MTD-008-05 | Corrected enforcement boundary. |
BR-CAP-PFM-MTD-008-06 | Corrected enforcement boundary. |
BR-CAP-PFM-MTD-009-12 | Corrected behavior statement; Corrected evidence classification; Replaced evidence reference; Added proof obligation. |
BR-CAP-PFM-MTD-010-09 | Added proof obligation. |
BR-CAP-PFM-MTD-012-04 | Corrected behavior statement; Corrected evidence classification; Replaced evidence reference. |
BR-CAP-PFM-MTD-012-11 | Corrected behavior statement. |
BR-CAP-PFM-MTD-013-02 | Corrected behavior statement. |
BR-CAP-PFM-MTD-014-07 | Added proof obligation. |
BR-CAP-PFM-MTD-015-06 | Corrected behavior statement; Added proof obligation; Corrected evidence classification; Replaced evidence reference. |
BR-CAP-PFM-MTD-017-08 | Replaced evidence reference; Corrected enforcement boundary. |
BR-CAP-PFM-MTD-018-07 | Corrected behavior statement. |
BR-CAP-PFM-MTD-019-10 | Added proof obligation. |
BR-CAP-PFM-MTD-001-10 | id; Corrected behavior statement; kind; Corrected enforcement boundary; Added proof obligation; Corrected evidence classification; Replaced evidence reference; origin. |
BR-CAP-PFM-MTD-012-15 | id; Corrected behavior statement; kind; Corrected enforcement boundary; Added proof obligation; Corrected evidence classification; Replaced evidence reference; origin. |
BR-CAP-PFM-MTD-015-09 | id; Corrected behavior statement; kind; Corrected enforcement boundary; Added proof obligation; Corrected evidence classification; Replaced evidence reference; origin. |
BR-CAP-PFM-MTD-018-13 | id; Corrected behavior statement; kind; Corrected enforcement boundary; Added proof obligation; Corrected evidence classification; Replaced evidence reference; origin. |
ATS-PFM-MTD-001-07 | id; title; level; proves; preconditions; steps; expected; negative; data_needs; bound_to; Corrected evidence classification; Replaced evidence reference. |
ATS-PFM-MTD-002-06 | id; title; level; proves; preconditions; steps; expected; negative; data_needs; bound_to; Corrected evidence classification; Replaced evidence reference. |
ATS-PFM-MTD-004-05 | id; title; level; proves; preconditions; steps; expected; negative; data_needs; bound_to; Corrected evidence classification; Replaced evidence reference. |
ATS-PFM-MTD-004-06 | id; title; level; proves; preconditions; steps; expected; negative; data_needs; bound_to; Corrected evidence classification; Replaced evidence reference. |
ATS-PFM-MTD-005-12 | id; title; level; proves; preconditions; steps; expected; negative; data_needs; bound_to; Corrected evidence classification; Replaced evidence reference. |
BR-CAP-PFM-MTD-005-12 | Added proof obligation. |
ATS-PFM-MTD-006-09 | id; title; level; proves; preconditions; steps; expected; negative; data_needs; bound_to; Corrected evidence classification; Replaced evidence reference. |
ATS-PFM-MTD-008-11 | id; title; level; proves; preconditions; steps; expected; negative; data_needs; bound_to; Corrected evidence classification; Replaced evidence reference. |
ATS-PFM-MTD-009-12 | id; title; level; proves; preconditions; steps; expected; negative; data_needs; bound_to; Corrected evidence classification; Replaced evidence reference. |
ATS-PFM-MTD-012-15 | id; title; level; proves; preconditions; steps; expected; negative; data_needs; bound_to; Corrected evidence classification; Replaced evidence reference. |
ATS-PFM-MTD-012-16 | id; title; level; proves; preconditions; steps; expected; negative; data_needs; bound_to; Corrected evidence classification; Replaced evidence reference. |
ATS-PFM-MTD-012-17 | id; title; level; proves; preconditions; steps; expected; negative; data_needs; bound_to; Corrected evidence classification; Replaced evidence reference. |
ATS-PFM-MTD-015-07 | id; title; level; proves; preconditions; steps; expected; negative; data_needs; bound_to; Corrected evidence classification; Replaced evidence reference. |
ATS-PFM-MTD-018-12 | id; title; level; proves; preconditions; steps; expected; negative; data_needs; bound_to; Corrected evidence classification; Replaced evidence reference. |
ATS-PFM-MTD-001-05 | level. |
ATS-PFM-MTD-008-08 | level. |
ATS-PFM-MTD-008-09 | level. |
JNY-PFM-MTD-006 | steps. |
BR-CAP-PFM-MTD-001-10 | Added post-commit retired-field search degradation and its partial-failure boundary. |
BR-CAP-PFM-MTD-012-15 | Added scaled-number storage and safe-range behavior. |
BR-CAP-PFM-MTD-015-09 | Added retention-duration validation. |
BR-CAP-PFM-MTD-018-13 | Added locks and existing-link maintenance after type deactivation. |
BR-CAP-PFM-MTD-014-08 | Added current-description and audience filtering of retained revisions. |
BR-CAP-PFM-MTD-018-12 | Removed explanatory text from the exact documentary heading reference. |
ATS-PFM-MTD-001-05, ATS-PFM-MTD-008-08, ATS-PFM-MTD-008-09 | Reclassified database integration proof from unit to API level. |
JNY-PFM-MTD-006 | Replaced unsupported browser-test provenance with observed configuration and description sources; narrowed the rendered-form promise and retained partial observation. |
JNY-PFM-MTD-002 | Limited the unauthorized archival branch to the permission declaration actually checked by its binding. |
MOD-PFM-MTD | Updated the rule and obligation inventory; retained source and ownership mapping. |
ID_REGISTRY | Reserved new rules, scenarios and findings before their artifacts. |
FINDINGS | Added eleven examination findings and retained the earlier thirty and three product questions. |
The behavior corrections distinguish asynchronous search rebuilding, the custom-object-only field limit, versioned replacement from unversioned field lifecycle requests, API purpose authorization, query recipes from saved views, changed hidden values from retained values, record archival from object archival, queued-event retention and refusal to end undated links. No observation was converted into an approval.
Added acceptance obligations
| Scenario | Final text | Evidence level | Binding |
|---|---|---|---|
ATS-PFM-MTD-001-07 | Undeclared field settings use stable defaults | api | Existing pinned assertions |
ATS-PFM-MTD-002-06 | Fixed fields precede custom properties | api | Existing pinned assertions |
ATS-PFM-MTD-004-05 | Removing an absent override reports no change | api | Existing pinned assertions |
ATS-PFM-MTD-004-06 | A replacement label retains authorship | api | Existing pinned assertions |
ATS-PFM-MTD-005-12 | Omitted presentation settings clear on replacement | api | Existing pinned assertions |
ATS-PFM-MTD-006-09 | Native fields lack the custom-object dependency safeguard | api | Existing pinned assertions |
ATS-PFM-MTD-008-11 | Malformed cursors are rejected | api | Existing pinned assertions |
ATS-PFM-MTD-009-12 | Activation and archival have distinct recipe effects | api | Proposed; finding records the missing proof |
ATS-PFM-MTD-012-15 | Untouched hidden values are retained | api | Proposed; finding records the missing proof |
ATS-PFM-MTD-012-16 | An active object permits deletion of an archived record | api | Proposed; finding records the missing proof |
ATS-PFM-MTD-012-17 | Scaled numeric storage respects safe precision | api | Existing pinned assertions |
ATS-PFM-MTD-015-07 | Invalid retention cannot run a sweep | api | Existing pinned assertions |
ATS-PFM-MTD-018-12 | Locks remain effective for retired types | api | Proposed; finding records the missing proof |
Final-text pass by artifact
Every prose body and human-readable rule, scenario, journey step, assertion, facet, lifecycle description and acceptance instruction received the OpenAI final-text pass. Proper product terms and immutable evidence references remain stable. Verification commits precede the separate per-artifact rewrite commits; later examination additions are also OpenAI-authored.
| Artifact | Final text scope |
|---|---|
FINDINGS.md | Identifier allocations and examination records |
ID_REGISTRY.md | Identifier allocations and examination records |
MOD-PFM-MTD | Metadata and Organization-defined Records |
ATS-PFM-MTD-001 | Identifier allocations and examination records |
ATS-PFM-MTD-002 | Identifier allocations and examination records |
ATS-PFM-MTD-003 | Identifier allocations and examination records |
ATS-PFM-MTD-004 | Identifier allocations and examination records |
ATS-PFM-MTD-005 | Identifier allocations and examination records |
ATS-PFM-MTD-006 | Identifier allocations and examination records |
ATS-PFM-MTD-007 | Identifier allocations and examination records |
ATS-PFM-MTD-008 | Identifier allocations and examination records |
ATS-PFM-MTD-009 | Identifier allocations and examination records |
ATS-PFM-MTD-010 | Identifier allocations and examination records |
ATS-PFM-MTD-011 | Identifier allocations and examination records |
ATS-PFM-MTD-012 | Identifier allocations and examination records |
ATS-PFM-MTD-013 | Identifier allocations and examination records |
ATS-PFM-MTD-014 | Identifier allocations and examination records |
ATS-PFM-MTD-015 | Identifier allocations and examination records |
ATS-PFM-MTD-016 | Identifier allocations and examination records |
ATS-PFM-MTD-017 | Identifier allocations and examination records |
ATS-PFM-MTD-018 | Identifier allocations and examination records |
ATS-PFM-MTD-019 | Identifier allocations and examination records |
CAP-PFM-MTD-001 | Keep the Record Catalogue Current |
CAP-PFM-MTD-002 | Describe Records for Shared Clients |
CAP-PFM-MTD-003 | Keep Configurability Within Product Scope |
CAP-PFM-MTD-004 | Use Workspace Labels for Standard Fields |
CAP-PFM-MTD-005 | Extend Records With Durable Custom Fields |
CAP-PFM-MTD-006 | Configure Field Requirements and Exposure |
CAP-PFM-MTD-007 | Prepare Image and File Uploads |
CAP-PFM-MTD-008 | Manage Shared Forms and Record Layouts |
CAP-PFM-MTD-009 | Bring a Custom Record Type Into Use |
CAP-PFM-MTD-010 | Make Custom Records Discoverable |
CAP-PFM-MTD-011 | Control Custom Record Audiences |
CAP-PFM-MTD-012 | Maintain Valid Custom Records |
CAP-PFM-MTD-013 | Retire or Publish Custom Records |
CAP-PFM-MTD-014 | Explain Custom Record Changes |
CAP-PFM-MTD-015 | Deliver Committed Record and Link Events |
CAP-PFM-MTD-016 | Load and Reconcile Record Files |
CAP-PFM-MTD-017 | Define Meaningful Record Relationships |
CAP-PFM-MTD-018 | Maintain Dated Links Between Records |
CAP-PFM-MTD-019 | Preserve Relationships Through Deletion and Merge |
CON-PFM-MTD-001 | Record Type |
CON-PFM-MTD-002 | Custom Field |
CON-PFM-MTD-003 | Form and Page Layout |
CON-PFM-MTD-004 | Custom Object |
CON-PFM-MTD-005 | Custom Record |
CON-PFM-MTD-006 | Relationship |
FEAT-PFM-MTD-01 | Record Type Catalogue |
FEAT-PFM-MTD-02 | Additional Fields and Attachments |
FEAT-PFM-MTD-03 | Record Presentations |
FEAT-PFM-MTD-04 | Organization-defined Record Categories |
FEAT-PFM-MTD-05 | Keeping Custom Records |
FEAT-PFM-MTD-06 | Linked Records |
JNY-PFM-MTD-001 | Create a club register and its first boat |
JNY-PFM-MTD-002 | Maintain a boat and inspect its changes |
JNY-PFM-MTD-003 | Limit a sensitive register to its assigned role |
JNY-PFM-MTD-004 | Define connections and maintain dated links |
JNY-PFM-MTD-005 | Apply deletion policies and consolidate duplicate endpoints |
JNY-PFM-MTD-006 | Add a contact field and inspect its description |
ACT-PFM-007 through ACT-PFM-012 | Rewritten identities of responsibility, goals and broad actions; permission references retained. |
MOD-PFM-MTD product-area row | Marked planning examined. |
Disagreements left open
No examination finding is treated as a product resolution. The findings register preserves evidence and affected identifiers for each item.
| Finding | Open issue |
|---|---|
FND-PFM-MTD-001 | The original registry scope included the eligibility milestone while omitting milestones for loads, events, console delivery and field capability. Several console paths were unavailable and implementation paths were missing. The draft’s registry update repairs that scope description. |
FND-PFM-MTD-002 | The extensibility inventory primarily describes integration registry and invocation work. Only three business-event delivery entries belong to this module; the remaining inventory stays with the integrations module. |
FND-PFM-MTD-003 | The relationship milestone remains in progress and lacks an Engineering Verified run. Its recorded layers passed, but verification is held for an owner-picker scenario associated with the earlier console milestone. Approved plans and decisions establish relationship intent; acceptance completion does not. |
FND-PFM-MTD-004 | The loads and events milestone remains proposed without an approved plan. Its record describes unlanded work even though the pinned tree contains load handlers, event storage, dispatch and sweeping. The affected capabilities retain proposed intent. |
FND-PFM-MTD-005 | The attachment milestone has no Engineering Verified run. Upload issuance is implemented, while uploader checking and web-address copying during save depend on shared assets and record owners beyond this module’s proof. Issuance does not apply a field-specific smaller size limit. |
FND-PFM-MTD-006 | The contact page designer stores draft and published documents in browser storage. Platform’s shared layout storage is therefore not the publication destination, and other browsers do not receive that publication. The standard expects shared configured layouts and leaves the engine choice open. |
FND-PFM-MTD-007 | The permission catalogue includes metadata, label and layout keys without corresponding route requirements. Publishing a permission resource does not establish an operation. Bulk custom-field access is consumed by dependent data-job routes. |
FND-PFM-MTD-008 | Four approved additional-field categories lack layout purposes: committee nominations, memberships, organizational units and membership applications. Their form and layout requests fail despite the standard’s associated presentation obligation. No in-scope deferral decision establishes an exception. |
FND-PFM-MTD-009 | Object settings accept and retain per-owner record and per-record link limits without enforcing them. An owner can receive records beyond the stored cap, contrary to the documented enforcement claim. |
FND-PFM-MTD-010 | Reset retains custom-object definitions, including active ones, while removing their properties and rules. Until package restoration, the retained definition lacks its naming property and cannot be replaced unchanged. The recorded reset decision does not settle property retention. |
FND-PFM-MTD-011 | A link-load correction replaces link attributes as a complete set. Supplying only primary clears omitted dates, position and notes; omitting an existing end date reopens the connection. Partial correction files can therefore change history without warning. |
FND-PFM-MTD-012 | The metadata contract assigns HTML sanitization to value storage, but custom-record writes convert and retain HTML without a sanitizing step. No scoped test proves sanitization, leaving a gap before markup reaches member or public consumers. |
FND-PFM-MTD-013 | Endpoint requirement flags are stored on relationship types but are not checked by custom-record or link writes. The documented owner responsibility therefore does not prevent a record from existing without its required connection. |
FND-PFM-MTD-014 | A deletion-check registration seam exists without a registered consumer. Cross-service cascades do not consult that seam, so future submission protections would need explicit integration to cover cascaded removal. |
FND-PFM-MTD-015 | Ownership predicates and exposure projections have tests, while member and public record routes remain absent under the recorded portal pause. Stored portal operation settings do not establish a delivered member workflow. |
FND-PFM-MTD-016 | The caller-organization default is accepted but resolves no value because the signed context supplies no organization. The available option consequently has no filling effect. |
FND-PFM-MTD-017 | Only custom-object records register the checker needed to enable uniqueness. Registered record categories therefore reject unique rules despite sharing the rule vocabulary. |
FND-PFM-MTD-018 | The builder-deletion browser test retains a title suggesting partial deletion. Its assertions instead prove refusal and complete rollback, matching the corrected all-or-nothing decision. Evidence strength follows those assertions. |
FND-PFM-MTD-019 | Platform retains relationship revisions for native endpoints, but CRM’s drawer reads CRM history alone. Staff do not see those linked-record changes in the contact or organization timeline; the service records this integration gap. |
FND-PFM-MTD-020 | The legacy custom-object inventory and README describe an earlier branch with no console screens and a pending console decision. The pinned tree contains screens and browser specifications under the later milestone approach. Legacy capabilities are superseded; the earlier rule inventory is a seed rather than a completed row-by-row reconciliation. |
FND-PFM-MTD-021 | The shared metadata contract enforces the obligation to declare forms and layouts with additional fields. Platform’s scoped tests do not demonstrate that contract refusal, so the rule retains documentary evidence pending an appropriate integration proof. |
FND-PFM-MTD-022 | The recorded decision limits relationship-type counts per workspace and endpoint category. Persistence does not enforce either limit; query description instead bounds its type read and logs overflow. |
FND-PFM-MTD-023 | The custom-navigation operation exists in routes but is absent from the contract’s route tables. Its availability is therefore implementation evidence with a documentation gap. |
FND-PFM-MTD-024 | The scoped modules contain eighty-six literal operation identities and three factory-generated health routes. Dependent custom-record data-job declarations belong to the data-job engine and are excluded from that literal count. |
FND-PFM-MTD-025 | The definition retains a legacy navigation hint alongside validated app placement. Writes do not reconcile the two settings, and the contract leaves removal of the older hint undecided. |
FND-PFM-MTD-026 | A bound test establishes its asserted behavior, not a passing execution at the pinned commits. Recorded live runs contain an owner-picker failure and earlier API failures, so current acceptance needs execution evidence. |
FND-PFM-MTD-027 | Transition compatibility supplies all capabilities to approved categories that omit declarations and warns on certain query registrations without refusing them. Owning-service declarations and removals from unapproved categories remain outside this module’s completed work. |
FND-PFM-MTD-028 | Role-restricted reach depends on Security’s object-scoped assignments. This module stores and applies the access mode; creating the scoped role assignment belongs to Security. |
FND-PFM-MTD-029 | Link-attribute updates and merge-driven link movements or endings emit no business announcements. Service debt records retain both omissions. |
FND-PFM-MTD-030 | The custom-record export key has no requiring route. Exports use the query layer, and custom-object dataset end-to-end confirmation remains recorded debt. |
FND-PFM-MTD-31 | The planning brief named by the examination job is absent from the starting checkout and the fetched default branch. Examination uses the supplied job instructions and pinned product records; draft compliance with that missing brief remains unknown. |
FND-PFM-MTD-32 | Indexed-field archival commits a degradation record and rebuild request; the search documents change later. The draft incorrectly promised immediate document rewriting. The corrected rule is observed in the archive coordinator, while its existing test binding demonstrates the completed rebuild. |
FND-PFM-MTD-33 | The field-count limit is checked only for custom objects. The draft extends it to registered record types; the corrected rule limits that claim to custom-object properties. |
FND-PFM-MTD-34 | Visibility validation checks submitted changes rather than every retained value. Changing a controlling property can leave an untouched hidden value stored. The added acceptance scenario is proposed because no existing binding proves this transition. |
FND-PFM-MTD-35 | Direct deletion does not reject a record merely because it is archived, provided its object is active and deletion checks pass. The draft says archived records accept only restoration. The correction and proposed deletion scenario distinguish record archival from object archival. |
FND-PFM-MTD-36 | Activation writes shared Explorer query recipes, rather than personal saved views. The object archive operation contains no recipe retirement call. The draft conflates those records and promises retirement; the corrected rule and a proposed scenario expose the actual boundary. |
FND-PFM-MTD-37 | Additional must-prove obligations lack a bound acceptance scenario: post-registration search degradation, custom-app lifecycle cleanup, history filtering and purge protection, queued-event retention, and relationship cleanup on workspace reset or deletion. Existing documentation and service code describe these behaviours; approval requires explicit proof at the relevant boundary. |
FND-PFM-MTD-38 | Upload issuance signs an expiring address and records an issue but does not consume a one-use token. The draft calls that address single-use without evidence. Issuance also validates the declaration rather than checking whether the named field exists or accepts the requested kind. Save-side enforcement remains a separate obligation. |
FND-PFM-MTD-39 | Some composite proof claims exceed the assertions in their bindings: collection retirement in registration, portal absence as a route inventory claim, and the contact-field journey rendering a newly created field in a browser. Database integration scenarios are corrected to the API tier; the contact journey is narrowed to description evidence and remains partially observed. Each listed test exists, but an execution pass and complete end-to-end proof are separate questions. |
FND-PFM-MTD-40 | Link maintenance rejects applicable record locks even after the relationship type is deactivated. The added rule and proposed acceptance scenario cover those service refusals; no existing bound test proves their combined lifecycle case. |
FND-PFM-MTD-041 | Current descriptions and audience exposure filter revision presentation, leaving archived property values retained but undisplayed. A focused archive-then-history acceptance binding is absent. The history record also identifies concurrent opposite-direction link capture as a deadlock case that depends on caller retry; no scoped proof establishes that retry boundary. |
The three retained product questions request decisions about reset retention, shared layout publication and combining native and Platform history. Recommendations use product language and do not assert that Andrew has chosen them.
Validation and verdict for Andrew
The required dependency install and corpus check pass with zero errors. All four corpus tests pass. Only authorized documentation paths changed, no workflow or reader files changed, and no deployment or push was performed.
The examined layer is a faithful, sourced planning description of the pinned implementation within the recorded findings and the unavailable-brief limitation. Its weakest area is complete acceptance proof for consumer presentation, deferred portal behavior and effects crossing service or asynchronous boundaries. Before design starts, Andrew should resolve the retained product questions, approve or revise proposed intent and require focused proof for the named findings.